Peg doll size rules FAQ

Peg doll size rules FAQ

Peg doll size rules FAQ

Sometimes we come across parts of the standard which are frustrating for some, and can cause issues in toy making. Its hard to be the deliverer of bad news in these cases, but in the name of toy safety we battle on.
One of these issues lately is the legal size of peg dolls, what’s ok?, what’s not? Is there exceptions?

This blog was written with the EN71-1 standards, the Europa guidance document for classifying toys, The Toy directives 2009/48/ec advisory document, The CPSC age determination and guidelines doc, and information and advice from a UK accredited lab in mind

The Play figures test

Thanks to Spencer for cutting us this amazing template B!

The EN71-1 standards state the lower size limit for peg dolls is over 64mm (so 65mm essentially)
When a peg doll is below this size, because its head is rounded/or semi rounded, its subjected to template B which is the test for rounded shaped objects for under 3s -which is shown on the picture to the left(demonstrated by an 8cm peg doll.) To pass template B, the head of the doll must not go through that hole completely.

The peg doll in the picture shown passes due to its height and does not need the template B test, however if it were shorter than 65mm it would fail.

This is still valid even if it passes the small parts cylinder.

Why can’t I just label for under 36 months and bypass this rule?

The answer to this lies in the appeal of the peg doll. Peg dolls are simplistic and human shaped, they don’t need any dexterity to be used, they are super small child appealing, they also are small and light and easy for very young children to handle.
In general the EN71-1 standards refer you to other documents for advice on tricky areas such as age classification by saying:

‘information relating to the age grading of toys and, in particular, which toys are intended for under 36 months and which toys are not, can be found in CR14379, the CPSC age determination guidelines, CEN/CENELEC Guide 11 and the European guidance documents’

in this instance for relevance in this blog they refer you to:
-the Europa docs (number 11 on the classification of toys intended for children under 3 years of age), ‘The Toy Safety Directive 2009/48/EC – an advisory document’
and also the CPSC age determination guidelines – these are so helpful in understanding the psychology of children and toys.
Though the CEN/CENELEC guide 14 also has information on child development and risk.

The criteria stated in the recommended Europa guidance docs for under 36 months are these:

(1) the psychology of children of under 3 years, particularly their need to “cuddle”;
(2) their attraction to objects “which are like them”: baby, small child, baby animal,
etc.;
(3) their mental development, particularly their capacity for abstraction, level of
knowledge, limited patience, etc.;
(4) their less developed physical abilities in terms of ease of movement, manual
dexterity, etc (the toy may be small and light for the child to handle it easily).

Further instructions for using warnings:

1) it is the children’s aptitudes to use a toy in accordance with its destination which
justify the choice to intend them for the children of more or less then 3 years old; if
this use can be gradual and start before three years to continue beyond, the toy has
to be appropriate for the youngest children;
(2) if a toy involves small parts that can be swallowed or inhaled or if there is a risk of
strangulation, this does not mean, ipso facto, that the toy is intended for children
of more than 3 years old;
(3) marking “is not appropriate for the children of less than 3 years old” (or of less
than 36 months) cannot have as a justification the economic realisation at the level
of the tests and the setting in conformity of the products; it cannot therefore be
found on a toy meeting the above criteria (for children less than 3)

 

Due to all of these factors, and that you must always CE mark for the youngest audience to which the toy is appealing (to keep them safe) Its not possible to use a warning saying they are not for under 36 months, and a warning may not protect you in terms of liability should the items be given to a child under 3 who chokes, or a child under 3 gets hold of them via a sibling and chokes because the toy appealed to them too.

The toy directives 2009/48/ec advisery document states:
Toys shall not bear one or more of the specific warnings set out in Part B of Annex V where that warning conflicts with the intended use of the toy, as determined by virtue of its function, dimension and characteristics.
Article 11 (1), third subparagraph, aims at preventing the misuse of warnings to circumvent the safety requirements. The misuse has occurred in the past in particular in case of warnings stating that the toy is not suitable for children under 36 months, which has been misused to escape from the small parts requirements applying to toys intended for children under 36 months. The wording of this provision is, however, general and prohibits the use of all of the specific warnings laid down in part B of Annex V that contradict the intended use of the toy. The intended use of the toy is determined by virtue of its function, dimension and characteristics.

So that basically says, you can’t ignore the guidance and stick a warning on if it contradicts the intended use of the toy – intended not being your intention, but by its function, dimension and characteristics.

The EN71-1 (Physical part of the toy standards) also recommends referring to ‘CPSC Age determination guidelines’ which is a comprehensive and helpful document on ages and stages for various toys which refers to peg dolls in several sections which you can find linked here  

To save you wading through all 300+pages, pages 4-5 explains age determination/classification of toys, and then, pages 85, 95, 100 and 105 reference the age appeal for peg dolls, for which they largely reference them for age 19-22 months, with also a reference to 12 month olds enjoying simple sets such as:

‘Small, simple play scenes like kitchens,
farms, gas stations, airplanes
Simple pop-up scenes like fire trucks
Simple play sets like those that have
vehicles with small figures’

 

What about using smaller peg dolls in a set?

Unless your set specifically appeals to over 3s in other ways, such as being a self assembly set for a larger toy, or in a game which would not be suitable for under 3s due to the complexities, no you cannot use smaller peg dolls even in a set due to the appeal for little ones.

Can I use smaller peg dolls if they are fixed into a bigger part of a toy?

Yes! if it passes all the physical tests you can fix the smaller peg doll into a bed, or a manger etc as it makes the toy larger, and also means the play figures test may not apply because the shape is changed.

I see that companies use 6cm peg dolls, why can big companies use smaller peg dolls with warnings and we can’t?

Its not really our place to comment on bigger companies and what they do.
As a small business we follow guidance from a UKAS accredited laboratory, who state that peg dolls appeal to under 3s. So to keep your liability to a minimum this is what we relay to you also. Its just safer that way for children and for your risk as a manufacturer.

When I buy blank peg dolls they come with a warning not for under 36 months? Why can I buy smaller blank peg dolls with this warning? Can I still use these?

Blank peg dolls are sold as a craft item and not as a finished toy item, and do not go through the same tests as a toy would. Craft items have a different criteria and it would be normal for them to have this warning. Craft sellers sell the items for home craft use and have no control over the final piece, which could then be turned into a framed artwork piece, or, if over the right size and with the right tests, could still be turned into a toy, even then without the initial warning applied as a craft item.

What can I do now?

Scaling up your sets are the best option to go for here. Make your biggest peg dolls larger, and then your 6.5cm can be your smallest dolls.
This may of course have an impact on your costs, but also, scale those up too! Don’t forget they are paying for beautiful quality handmade items, not mass produced and your prices should always reflect this too!

Can I make my items not for play? how?
By making your peg dolls immobile (either by ideally framing or mounting them) you can then ensure the items are not for play, and affix the warning that its not suitable for under 3s, and that it is not a toy. By doing this the toy standards do not apply.

Whats the minimum age for peg dolls?
Toys for babies under ten months have to undergo extra tests such as template A. This is due to the risk of impaction when a baby mouthes toys laying down. Although peg dolls are not intended as baby toys, they are small,lightweight and easily held by babies.
This is why most peg dolls are recommended age labelled from 10 months when a child is sitting (some prefer 12 months)

More information

An accredited lab would be the best source of advice for this type of question.
Your local trading standards may also be helpful, but bear in mind not all are experts in toy safety, and some will charge.
other blog posts on peg dolls:
Peg Doll Problems

CE marking Wooden toys in general blog posts:
Classifying Wooden toys or toys with hard elements

Wooden toys

Toy appeal  for age classification

%d bloggers like this: