Appendix 3 Annex 2 – Further Chemical Restrictions

Appendix 3 Annex 2 – Further Chemical Restrictions

Appendix 3 Annex 2 – Further Chemical Restrictions Explained

This blog was written with the Toy Directives, Oeko-tex restrictions, REACH restrictions in mind.
I’m going to start this one with do not panic, you have likely been conforming to these chemicals without realising it, due to them being covered in restrictions such as REACH, and Oeko-tex, or simply by them not applying to the type of toy you are creating.

Knowledge is power in all terms of toy making and when it comes to the chemical regulations its a really tough one to understand. There are several banned substances for toys for under 3s which do not get covered by en71-3, (they are covered by EN71-9,10,11 but these aren’t harmonised standards, so do not need to be tested for those to comply as such). These are listed in the The Toy Directives rather than the standards, which are free to read online if you wanted to.

These chemical regulations not set out in the standards still need to be applied to in terms of assessing if they are relevant to you, and gathering up evidence to say they are within limits if they do.

What are they?
There are 11 banned substances listed so I am going to break them down for you so you know what they are, but be sure to do your own research into your own materials, as these lists may not cover everything:

Tris (2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP, CAS 115-96-8)
These are flame retardants which slow the spread of flame on materials such foam in furniture etc. They are on the REACH high concern list so are not likely to be in materials which comply to REACH and isn’t used in the EU but could be on imported goods.
Its forbidden in OEKO-TEX testing

Tris (2-chloro-1-methylethyl) phosphate (TCPP, 13674-84-5)
Tris [2-chloro-1-(chloromethyl)ethyl] phosphate (TDCP, 13674-87-8)
Are flame retardant which are used in foams, and resins, potentially textiles too.
Risks in: foam, resins (plywood mdf potentially), Textiles (low)

Bisphenol A (BPA, CAS 80-05-7)
BPA you may have heard of in terms of ‘BPA free’, its a hardener for plastics.
Risks in: BPA is used in plastics, and resins

Formamide (CAS 75-12-7)
Formamide is mostly used in foams such as EVA foam, resins.
Risks in: Foam toys

1,2-Benzisothiazol- 3(2H)-one (BIT, CAS 2634-33-5)
5-Chloro-2-methylisothiazolin-3(2H)-one (CMI, CAS 26172-55-4)
2-Methylisothiazolin-3(2H)-one (MI, CAS 2682-20-4)
3 to 1 mixture of 5-chloro-2-methylisothiazolin-3(2H)-one (CMI) and 2-methylisothiazolin-3(2H)-one (MI) (CMI:MI (3:1), CAS 55965-84-9)
All of these can be used in paint for anti fungal properties, so should not be in paints for children to paint with in toy kits, the risks are higher in the wet paint rather than the dried paint – its acceptable to use these on toys when dried/sealed.
Risks in: Paint, fabric paint
1,2-Benzisothiazol- 3(2H)-one is usually labelled on paints such as fabric paints as an allergy warning but not always.

Phenol (CAS 108-95-2)
Phenol is banned in things like cosmetics and toys in the EU but is still used in Epoxy resins
Risk in: Resins, resins in plywood, MDF etc
Oeko-tex restrict Phenols

Formaldehyde (CAS 50-00-0)
Formaldehyde can be used in liquid toys like bubbles as a preservative, it can be used in glues and resins(mdf and plywood), on fabrics and leathers
Formaldehyde is restricted in Oeko-tex fabrics
Risk in: Glues, MDF,plywood, fabric, leathers, bubble mixture

Aniline
Aniline can be used in pigment/dyes/manufacturing
its use is restricted in oekotex materials (class 1, and all classes with annex 6 tests)

Risks in: Aniline can be used in aqueous materials (finger paints) and in fabrics/yarns etc

Also to add:

Azo Dyes
Azo dyes are usually used as bright coloured dyes for things like leather and fabrics, they are banned in EU, Japan, China, Vietnam, and India.
They are restricted under REACH and also OEKO-TEX. This is a very low risk for textiles from well established and known manufacturers.

Nitrosamines
Nitrosamines are found in rubber and plastics to increase their elasticity. They have very low limits to adhere to in plastics, rubber/silicone (especially for toys for under 3s) balloons and also finger paints.
Risks in: plastics, silicones, latex, paint

Phthalates
Phthalates are found in plastics to increase life and elasticity, and also cosmetics. They are banned in certain countries in certain products, but not all.
RIsks in: plastics and PVC

How can I ensure compliance?
Assess your materials research whether any of these restrictions apply to the materials you are using, then get confirmation of any addition safety certificates and see if the restricted substances are covered by those. Any thing you can’t get a certificate covering, get confirmation.
Fabric/yarn toys: Most of the time when you are asking for en71-3 certificates from manufacturers, they tend to send over certificates such as REACH, and OEKOTEX. They are usually happy to tell you that they don’t use any flame retardants and formaldehyde. You can print the emails and certificates and add them to your technical files.

For wooden toy makers: Consider your base wood products and try to avoid ply and MDF unless you can get information on what is in them and whether they are affected by the restricted substances. Check with Glue manufacturers for content, check with manufacturers for sealant content, and any other finish on the wood.

Working with silicones and plastic: Check content of plastics and ensure they do not contain of the listed substances, Nitrosamines and Phthalates. Food grade plastics and silicones are best.

In craft kits: Ensure your paints comply with the antifungals if children are painting with them (note if they already have the CE/UKCA this should all be covered and you just need to keep evidence)

more info:

Chemical Guidance

%d bloggers like this: